I don't disagree that technology needs to be in classrooms. Nor do I disagree that technology can be used to engage students or promote learning. I do disagree with one of Prensky's main pushes for allowing technology to be in the classroom: gaming. Another area I disagree is the full on collaboration of students with teachers on what technology to use and how to use it to teach and measure their learning. Finally, core knowledge should be included, not just 21st century skills.
There are many assumptions made about learning styles by Prensky’s article. Namely, that there is one learning style now, the style that requires picture experience or gaming. While it is true that we are aware of these kinds of learners now, it is not true that every “digital native” is that kind of learner.
Collaboration between students and teachers sounds great and would promote stronger classrooms, however, when the students direct fully or equally, what is the purpose of the teacher? Where is core knowledge going to come in? Prensky said that teachers would be guiding students in their self-selected education. I am progressive too but I still believe that children and teens need guidance and structure. Boundaries don’t have to inhibit creative learning. Children and teens do have great ideas for how to integrate technology but to allow them to select how they will be graded and by what criteria is not going to allow for accountability in learning. There have to be standards.
Teachers don’t have empathy just core knowledge? According to Prensky, teachers are only chosen based on what they know. This is a very important factor, yes, however, most teachers do care about their students. Bureaucracy often prevents teacher creativity in the classroom. A teacher saying, ‘it’s okay you didn’t do your homework, life is hard, you get an extra day and I will grade you the same” but not allowing other students more time to improve their work isn’t merciful, they are unfair. Students are going to learn responsibility this way but Prensky believes it is also the job of the teacher to teach responsibility to the student.
“We can no longer use either our 20th century knowledge or our training as a guide to what is best for them educationally.”
This quote from Prensky’s article makes it seem like knowledge has changed and past knowledge is no longer useful. Knowledge of technology has foundations in history. Without past knowledge, the advances we make today would not exist. Either we learn from past mistakes or we build off something that worked. Forgetting everything we learned and are trained to do will only leave a greater learning curve. 21st century skills weren’t born out of the Y2K bug.
Something I learned in undergrad for leading youth group is that programs (the way we present truth or knowledge) should not direct the truth or knowledge presented, they should aid the passing of the knowledge but in the event of power outage or budget cuts, the students should still be able to learn. They shouldn’t come for the programming; they should come for the knowledge. It is possible to over emphasize technology so much that education, core knowledge, gets lost or programmed out. Prensky has some great ideas for teaching, like using video games, and in certain situations and classrooms that will work. There is no one stop fix to improving education, it requires situational, intentional teaching.